Compare Bay Shore Historical Society Hotels

"My two sons and I stayed at this airy, bright, cute cottage on the canal. We arched the ducks dive for food and hold their own against the current, enjoying the privacy of the back yard. The open floor plan makes it very bright and welcoming. There is a long driveway for parking (probably could fit 3 cars back to back), a close walk to the water (1 block?) and restaurants. The town of Bay Shore is super quaint and walkable. Couple of things to be aware of: no dishwasher or garbage disposal so that ultimately curtailed our cooking. The stairs to the two bedrooms are rather steep with odd sized risers. It could make for treacherous up and down depending on your age. The primary is big, the other room with the twin and full is small but fine.Host Julio was responsive. When he asked how check in went and I told him we were having problem with the TV he said he could send someone over straightaway. We enjoyed our long weekend at this cute cottage. Enjoy your trip!"

"We had an amazing time on a great property!Traveled from California with my husband kids and their spouses. Met up with family on Long Island and the house was perfect for a family get together. Communication with the host was easy. Check in and check out were a breeze. Looking forward to coming back!"

"Large enough to sleep 12 adults and 8 children without difficulty! The game room for kids is fabulous and the master bath was a dream come true! Will stay again when visiting Long Island. May plan a summer beach week since so close to Beaches on the South Shore."

"The property was as advertised. It was clean and there was plenty of room for my family of 4. The place is updated and has large tvs in each room. We all agreed that beds were awesome and made for a great nights sleep. The location was close to major highways, making it easy to get anywhere we needed to go. I would definitely stay here again. Thank you for a great stay!."